Hiring for Culture Without Hiring the Same Person Every Time

When you've spent time building a strong retail or hospitality team, it's natural to want to protect what makes it work.
You want people who not only work well with colleagues, but understand the customer experience your business is trying to deliver. Especially if you're replacing a trusted employee, finding somebody who fits into the existing team is a priority.
But there's a difference between hiring somebody who shares your company values and hiring somebody who reminds you of the people already working for you.
It's easy to favour candidates who feel familiar, but this can mean overlooking somebody who brings valuable skills or a different perspective.
So, how do you hire for culture without limiting the people you're willing to consider?
Understand What Your Culture Actually Looks Like
Before deciding whether somebody is a good cultural fit, you need to be clear about what your workplace culture involves.
It's more than whether people get along or not. Culture is reflected in how employees communicate, approach customers, handle problems and support one another during difficult shifts, so you need to think about what genuinely matters to your business.
If teamwork is important, what does that look like during a busy Saturday? Perhaps it's somebody stepping in to help an overwhelmed colleague rather than focusing entirely on their own responsibilities.
Being specific gives you something meaningful to assess during recruitment, rather than relying on whether you personally like somebody.
Don't Confuse Familiarity With Suitability
Imagine you're interviewing two candidates for a Supervisor position.
One has a similar personality to your existing team, has worked for familiar retailers and immediately builds a good rapport with you.
The other has a different background and takes longer to get into the conversation, but gives thoughtful examples of handling customers and taking responsibility.
You might leave feeling more positive about the first candidate, even though the second demonstrated equally relevant skills, and this is where unconscious bias can influence hiring decisions.
Getting along with somebody isn't a problem. But when that connection becomes more important than their ability to do the job, you risk overlooking strong candidates.
Look for Shared Values, Not Identical Personalities
A positive workplace culture doesn't mean everybody needs to communicate or behave in exactly the same way.
Some employees are naturally outgoing and confident approaching customers. Others are quieter but particularly good at listening, understanding individual needs and resolving complicated problems, but both can deliver excellent customer service.
The same applies to teamwork. One person might be comfortable taking the lead during a busy shift, whilst another consistently notices when colleagues need support.
Rather than deciding what personality would suit your team, focus on the behaviours that matter to your business.
Think Carefully About How You Advertise the Role
Your job advert influences who decides to apply before you've even started reviewing CVs, so it's worth looking at how you describe your ideal candidate.
For example, asking for an "outgoing personality" might seem appropriate for a customer-facing retail job, but does the position require somebody who's naturally extroverted, or somebody who can communicate confidently and provide excellent service?
Those aren't necessarily the same thing.
Be clear about essential skills and working expectations. If certain experience can be developed through training, consider whether it genuinely needs to be listed as a requirement.
The aim isn't to make every vacancy suitable for everybody, it's to avoid discouraging capable candidates through unnecessarily narrow descriptions.
Make Interviews About Evidence, Not First Impressions
Interviews should help you understand how somebody approaches situations they'll encounter at work, so rather than asking whether you'd enjoy working with a candidate, think about what you actually need to learn from them.
For a retail or hospitality position, you might ask:
- Tell me about a time you supported a colleague during a particularly busy shift.
- How have you handled a customer who was unhappy with the service they received?
- Can you give an example of when you disagreed with somebody at work and how you approached it?
These questions give candidates opportunities to demonstrate judgement, communication skills and teamwork. For somebody entering the industry, you could use a realistic workplace scenario instead.
It's also worth asking candidates the same core questions and agreeing on what strong answers should demonstrate beforehand. That way, you're comparing relevant evidence rather than simply remembering who made the best first impression.
Don't Rule Out Different Career Backgrounds
It's understandable that employers often look for candidates with experience in similar businesses. Somebody who's worked in the same environment may already understand many of its demands.
But direct industry experience isn't always essential.
A hospitality employee moving into retail, for example, might already have experience handling complaints, working towards sales targets and managing several customer requests at once.
Somebody from another customer-facing industry may have developed valuable leadership or problem-solving skills.
Certain positions will require specific technical knowledge, but where skills can transfer or be developed, consider what somebody can genuinely bring rather than focusing entirely on where they've worked before.
Get Another Perspective Before Deciding
Involving another relevant colleague in recruitment can provide a more balanced perspective.
A Store Manager might focus on operational experience, whilst somebody working alongside the new employee may notice different strengths.
However, more interviewers don't automatically remove bias, so agree on the criteria beforehand and encourage everyone to give specific feedback.
Comments such as "they didn't seem like one of us" don't explain whether somebody can perform the role. Instead, discuss what each candidate demonstrated and whether there are genuine concerns about meeting the position's requirements.
Give New Employees Room to Contribute
Hiring somebody with a different perspective is one thing. Making sure they feel comfortable contributing once they've joined is another.
New employees need time to understand your processes and expectations, but they may also notice things established team members have become used to.
Perhaps they've seen a more practical way of organising a task or have experience handling a particular customer issue.
Not every suggestion will be appropriate, and some existing processes are there for good reasons, but employees should feel comfortable asking questions and sharing ideas without worrying that doing things differently means they don't belong.
Build the Right Team, Not the Same Team
Hiring for culture should help you find people who share your business values and understand your standards. It shouldn't mean recruiting the same type of person every time a vacancy opens.
Be clear about what matters, assess candidates fairly and recognise that strong employees don't all have identical personalities or career backgrounds.
For retail and hospitality employers, the aim is to find people who deliver excellent service, support colleagues and contribute to the business.
Sometimes, the person who brings something different to your team is exactly what your business needs.
Looking for people who can make a positive contribution to your business? Discover how Switch Roles can help you reach candidates looking for their next opportunity in retail and hospitality.
You might also be interested in
The latest news, trends, and career advice for people who work in, or want to work in, retail and hospitality.

How to Move From Store Management Into a Head Office Retail Role

How to Negotiate Salary for Your Next Retail or Hospitality Role
Your next move starts here.
Retail and hospitality's best employers are waiting. Find the role that fits, or explore the brands worth working for.



